2010年2月24日水曜日

Final presentation -International Christian University-




Self-Reflection

a) The process of preparation and rehearsal
b) The effectiveness of the introduction
c) The persuasiveness and organization of the content in the body
d) The conclusion and Q&A
e) Use of visuals
f) Body language: Eye contact, facial expression, gestures, and posture
g) Use of voice
h) Other points (as you like)


a) The process of preparation and rehearsal:
Unlike other presentations I had so far in this class, it was a GROUP work and therefore powerpoint visuals and the speech content needed to be shared with my members beforehand. Unfortunately, we did not have time for rehearsal. However, we spent so much time on making slides after the class as well as at home using emails. Despite the fact that we couldn't make it to gather up for rehearsal, we were prepared enough for our presentation in terms of making coherency in our individual speeches. Each of us (Mai, Sho and myself) was working very well for research and creating PP slides.

b) The effectiveness of the introduction:
The introduction was made by Mai, and I believe it was very effective as she proposed a question with impressive slides she made. The way she connected the question to our theme (ICU)was also very effective and natural(Global issues, How could they be solved, What we need, People who can take actions needed, ICU is providing active human resources). Rather than starting the presentation simply from the introduction of ICU, I think that making general question helps more to grab the audiences' attention.

c) The persuasiveness and organization of the content in the body:
I believe that the organization of the content was very well done as we spent a long time on making PP slides. Each of us successfully connected our individual speech to another, and moreover, mentioning our names and reflecting what others talked about in our own section made the presentation very organized as a whole.
In terms of persuasiveness, we could have made it better. As Matt gave us a question in the Q&A session, we did not clearly mention how much money on what we would be spending on if we received the financial aid. This vagueness made the entire presentation less persuasive compared to others, which the plans for spending money was clearly stated. We had been aware of this problem before the actual presentation, but could not propose the plan since we had no time and also since we were not sure at all about the ICU's real expense distribution. We tried to achieve persuading the audiences by vocal controls and non-verbal expressions, and it seems we were successful in doing so on the video, but could have been even better by changing the content.

d) The conclusion and Q&A:
The conclusion Sho made was effective as the slides he made were also visually impressive. Each of us made sure about the question by restating what the audience said, and answered clearly.

e) Use of visuals:
Thanks to the great techno-genius Mai, I'm sure that the visuals of this presentation was very much sophisticated. We used a lot of pictures which certainly worked to gain the attention. Just for the future presentation, a little bit less use of words per slide could make it even better. The theme was rather a serious one, so the AEP members told me that they took time to read the text and to understand the main message of each slide.

f) Body language: Eye contact, facial expression, gestures, and posture:
My personal goal for this presentation was to make strong, persuasive body language. Compared to the first presentation I made in this class, I improved in controlling these non-verbal communication. Although I had notes with me while presenting, I tried not to look at them too much and instead I focused on making eye contacts. Our topic was about our own university and so that we had been discussing that we should not be too serious. Watching the recorded video, we were all tranquil, and were making gestures appropriate to the topic.

g) Use of voice:
What I think I improved the most through this presentation is the use of pause and stress. To show my confidence and calmness, I used pauses as much as possible and for the words which I thought were important like "harmony in diversity"and "essential", I put stress. There is even more to improve, but my use/control of voice was appropriate and worked to create the persuasiveness in the speech.

h) Other points (as you like)
I realized that I sometimes make "fake" smiles to hide my nervousness. It makes myself seem less confident. For the next future presentation, I hope to quite this habit.

2 件のコメント:

  1. Impressions:
    Very calm, attractive, concise and passionate.

    Good points of his/her group's presentation:
    The presentation was persuasive with showing graphs and effective examples. I was impressive how each of the member answered the questions at last. They were appropriate and very clear.

    Good points of individual presenting:
    You were speaking in a calm way, and you emphasized the important parts using stress and pause. Not only the content of the presentation but also the way you presented(with confidence including good eye contact) was great! I like the examples you used(alumni, your friends) because they were supporting what you wanted to say and easy for us to understand.

    Suggestions:
    Although the slides were effective and great, some included many words so having less words might make it even better. Also if you had some experience or ideas of yourself, you might want to share in the presentation.
    I enjoyed very much!:)

    返信削除
  2. Hi Miki,

    Impressions:

    Your group's presentation on why people should donate money to ICU was quite persuasive. I have listened to several speeches by the ICU President or Dean about why liberal arts is important, and I think your group's explanation was equally effective and even better in many respects! This was because you showed how liberal arts education trains people who will take action to make a difference and become the central players who will move projects in Africa or Haiti. All points seemed supported by clear concepts and good examples such as Service Learning or the activities of ICU Alumni. The final points about why more money is needed could have used some more financial specifics, but the general points were well-explained.

    Your Good Points:

    -Nice transition from Mai and preview of points.
    -Good explanation of the social benefits from multilingual/multiculturalism (more than bilingual!). -The Malawi example in Service Learning was particularly strong and the alumni section was good too.
    -Nice friendly, rhythmic, professional speaking voice. Very good eye contact, posture and gestures too.
    -Nice summary and transition to Sho. Nicely done in spite of not having much group rehearsal time.

    Suggestions:

    -As you mentioned, the point of "financial difficulty" left a question mark in the minds of listeners because it was not supported specifically. Avoid mentioning claims you will not support.

    -This is a picky point, but the "social benefit" of the alumni perhaps could have been explained a little more.

    -I didn't noticed the "false smiles" but keep gaining experience with speaking with the style and effect you want to achieve.

    -Those are the only points in my notes. A few phrases could have been smoother, but that is natural because you were speaking with eye contact from your heart rather than reading a prepared script. I think that was a good choice.

    Very nice work on this presentation and good luck in future presentations!

    Mark

    返信削除